Asian Stowaways: Why Ahab’s Caucasian roots are a problem

Abby Larson

ENG 2201

Blog #10

Asian Stowaways: Why Ahab’s Caucasian roots are a problem

If one reads Moby Dick as a religious allegory, one immediately sees the problem presented by Ahab’s white skin. If the White Whale is to be portrayed as imposing, organized religion placed on other ethnicities by white people, Ahab’s Caucasian roots are most definitely a problem. Why would a white man have a problem with a white whale? The answer is found in Ahab’s allegiance with the Oriental stowaways. 

In 1807, missionaries first began to explore the Asiatic countries. Robert Morrison of the London Missionary Society spent 25 years translating the Bible into the Chinese language, but found resistance in the Chinese and only won over 10 individuals to the Christian faith. The Chinese have certain fundamental laws that prohibit wizards, witches, and all superstitions. In 1814, another clause was added to these laws which outlawed Christianity. In addition, Britain was constantly trying to force the Chinese into trade with the rest of the world. In short, China and other Asian countries were resistant to religious change, but the rest of the white Christian world continued to impose themselves. Therefore, if Melville was aware of these events (which he most certainly was), these events could be applied to Moby Dick.

Now, if one takes this allegory of religion and looks at Moby Dick through that particular lens, then one can clearly see how Ahab’s Caucasian roots are a major difficulty. Because Melville could not place an Oriental individual as the captain of the Pequod, he had to find another way of introducing the Asian element into the narrative. He does this by having Ahab secretly hide away several “yellow men” to help him fight Moby Dick. By only placing these Asian men in Ahab’s boat, Melville is showing his audience that Ahab is the symbol for the Asian countries that were being imposed upon and had been forced to accept trade agreements they did not want and religions they did not think they needed. This unwillingness to accept any new way of life and the forcing of such customs on a people anyways are exemplified in the removal of Ahab’s leg; even though Ahab did not die in his encounter with Moby Dick,  a little piece of himself was taken away, a piece that is essential to his survival and must now be replaced with a man-made replacement.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Sunset and Dusk: No, this isn’t a Twilight parody

Abby Larson

ENG 2201

Blog #9

Sunset and Dusk: No, this isn’t a Twilight parody

After Crazy Captain Ahab has convinced his crew to help him in his pursuit of Moby Dick, the sun begins to set and Ahab and Starbuck reflect on the events that had just taken place. While Ahab rants and raves, praising himself for his courage and fortitude, Starbuck’s reason and contemplations about life show the audience the dichotomy between insane zealots and level headed rational individuals.

Ahab’s rant after the recruitment of the men involves the maniacal, prideful lifting up of himself. Ahab says “I” almost 30 times in this short passage, and every time he mentions himself, it is only to uplift his own accomplishments. “Tis iron-that I know-not gold. Tis split too-that I feel; the jagged edge galls me so, my brain seems to beat against the solid metal; aye, steel skull, mine; the sort that needs no helmet in the most brain-battered fight!” This last statement is interesting in that it implies that Ahab needs no help or protection no matter how hard or difficult the fight may be; however, he just finished convincing his entire crew to help him chase and kill Moby Dick. It is almost as if Ahab is so crazy that he thinks he can kill the White Whale all by himself, but in his brief moments of sanity, realizes he needs someone to help him accomplish his goal. Ahab is the perfect picture of a self-reliant, yet egotistical man who believes that he can handle anything and needs no help from anyone. Because of this presentation of Ahab in chapter 37, the subsequent chapter entitled Dusk is starkly contrasted as the reader gets an inside look into the thoughts of Starbuck.

Starbuck’s contemplations are vastly different from Ahab’s. Whereas the crazy captain rambles on about his own “accomplishments” and how he intends to take revenge, Starbuck is left wondering how in the world he got roped into the entire mess. “My soul is more than matched; she’s overmanned; and by a madman!” Starbuck is completely confused and has no idea how Ahab was able to convince him to take part in this mad venture. However, instead of dwelling on his own plight, Starbuck’s thoughts wander into life contemplations and how revelry followed by silence is like life itself. “Hark! the infernal orgies! that revelry is forward! mark the unfaltering silence aft! Methinks it pictures life.” Starbuck is in the most difficult portion of his life; he has just been roped into an adventure that he clearly wants no part in, but instead of dwelling on his misfortunes, he considers life as a whole and how Ahab’s madness fits into it all. By portraying Starbuck as a philosopher of life instead of a selfish, egotistical maniac, Melville is able to show the reader the difference between being self absorbed and looking crazy and being able to step back and look at the whole picture like a wise individual. 

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Body and Soul Connections

Kendra Cowart

“The Facts in the Case of M. Valdemar”

By Edgar Allen Poe

 

Body and Soul Connections

            After I first read this short piece by the famous – or infamous – Edgar Allen Poe, I questioned its actual purpose. At a glance, it seems that it is meant simply to horrify the audience, like a ghost story. M. Valdemar is ill, is mesmerized, and is now a dead pile of putrescence – a very simple, but disgusting, story. Although this short piece of fiction does come off as a mere tall tale, I do find that after a bit of contemplation, this story does more than only entertain. It supports the belief of an afterlife with science; it regards life scientifically, but ironically can never really explain it. Many other pieces of literature written around the United States’ Romantic period also meshes science with the supernatural, but does not always entertain ideas of the afterlife so blatantly. Poe does confirm that an afterlife exists; however, that is all it confirms. The story leaves the reader with many questions concerning what comes after death, and especially questions whether or not the body and soul are connected.

When M. Valdemar dies, he is still “active:” his voice is heard from outside his body. He tells our narrator “I have been sleeping – and now – now – I am dead” (2544). From the first impression of this statement, we can tell that his soul is functioning even though his body is not. This leads one to believe that his soul is completely separate from his body. This is further proven in the text when the narrator inspects M. Valdemar’s body, only to find that he cannot draw blood or find any other signs of vitality besides occasional vibrations of the tongue (2545). Although his tongue moves, we know that his soul is separate because after death, his voice comes from all over the room. Until the disintegration of his body, every clue tells us that M. Valdemar’s soul is separate.

As M. Valdemar’s body decays in a matter of seconds, we are to believe that his soul was attached to his body. Just as before, the “sleepwalker’s” voice is heard from all over, and the tongue moves as well. However, this time the tongue is described with extra emphasis. Before he literally crumbles, M. Valdemar screams “’dead! dead!’ absolutely bursting from the tongue and not from the lips of the sufferer” (2546). Although the eyes are often seen as a direct connection to the soul, Poe suggests that it is instead the tongue. The fact that the tongue shows signs of life after death implies that soul exists in synch with the body; if the soul is ‘alive’ and the body exists, the person as a whole still exists. When M. Valdemar’s body crumbles, his soul disappears from mortal view. Though we have seen his soul after his life, we are still left wondering what it was that came next for him. Like the unexpected ending, we cannot know M. Valdemar’s final ending; it is ambiguous.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Walker’s Appeal: A Question of Humanity (6)

Stephanie Arrowood

Eng 2210

25 October 2011

Blog 6

Walker’s Appeal: A Question of Humanity

In David Walker’s Appeal to the Coloured Citizens of the World, he compares the white Christian slaveholders to the Egyptian Pharaoh who enslaved the Israelites during the time of Moses in the Old Testament. Walker stresses that Pharaoh was a heathen, hinting that Walker feels he can excuse Pharaoh for his cruelty because Pharaoh does not worship the Christian God. Throughout Article One of Appeal… Walker’s underlying question asks, “How can Christians excuse slavery?”

Walker compares the treatment of Israelite slaves to African American slaves. He states that Israelite slaves were treated with more humanity than African American slaves. Although Pharaoh offered Moses an Egyptian wife and power his brethren, Moses declined in order to remain loyal to his people. Moses surprised Pharaoh in his decision because Moses was raised as an Egyptian prince by Pharaoh and his wife. Walker includes this story of Moses to highlight that African American slaves were neither permitted to marry whites nor permitted to hold a position of power. Again, Walker stresses the treatment of slaves under Christian slaveholders is worse than treatment of slaves under the heathen Egyptian Pharaoh in the time of Moses.

Walker states regarding the Christians, “While they were heathens, they were too ignorant for such barbarity. But being Christians, enlightened and sensible, they are completely prepared for such hellish cruelties” (1993). An underlying note of sarcasm exists in Walker’s statement, however, the statement equates enlightenment with barbarity. Normally the term “heathen” is equated with barbarity, but this interesting twist suggests that the “heathens” are not cruel and barbarous like the Christians. Walker seems to reverse the roles of history and suggest that Christians were the original “heathens” with barbaric ways and greedy motives. He suggests that the people the Christians called “heathens” were actually better without Christian (barbaric and greedy) influence.

Walker is unable to answer the question of “How can Christians excuse slavery.” However, a person could suggest that Christian slaveholders did not think of their slaves as humans. This is evident in their treatment of the slaves and laws against slaves having any legal or moral rights. Since the Christian slaveholders did not consider their slaves as humans, they treated them as though they were property. Walker states that the treatment of slaves is inhumane. Who is more human, the slave or the slaveholder?

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

From Creation to Takeover: How the Spaniards Justified Ruling over the Indians

Kelsey Harris

ENGL 2210

Blog #1 Redo

“From Creation to Takeover: How the Spaniards Justified Ruling over the Indians”

The Spanish read “Requerimiento” to the natives as soon as they are on land.  They read it despite the fact that the natives do not understand their language and therefore have no idea what they are saying.  This however does not matter as it gives the Spaniards justification for the “violence, death, theft, and enslavement” of the natives (132).

This justification is upheld through the Christianity and the passing of power throughout the years.  This passing of power starts with the “one man and one woman” created by God (132).  The next major person of power is St. Peter which God deems to “be the lord and superior of all the men in the world” enabling him to makes rules for all the men he ruled over (132).  This passing of power continues through the Pope to pontiffs.  Through one of these pontiffs, the Spaniards again justify their actions.  They claim that a certain pontiff “made donation of these islands and mainland to the aforesaid king and queen and to their successors (132).”  Therefore the natives have no choice but to follow the rule of Spaniards now and for all the years to come.

The Spaniards also justify their actions through their declaration of rules and consequences for the natives.  They can by “their own free will” decide to “become Christians” following everyone in power associated with Christianity (133).  This is not so much free will as an unspoken rule to convert.  By following this rule, the natives can essentially save their people from slavery and their lands from being overtaken, according to the document.  If they do not comply with the unspoken rule, then the Spaniards have free rein to “make war,” “make slaves of [the wives and children],” and “take away [their] goods (133).” All of these statements give the Spaniards the right to what they wish because the justification is in writing.

Essentially, the Spaniards did not need to give the natives a history lesson on Christianity.  The natives do not necessarily care about its history.  As far as the hand down of power, the natives will not understand some of the complex political systems of the church and state nor the titles associated with them.  The rules and consequences are easy enough to understand but there is not any true choice associated with them.  The main point however is that the natives do not know the language of the Spaniards and therefore cannot comprehend any of the document being hastily read to them.  Whether or not the Spaniards know this does not matter.  The point is that the natives are doomed from the beginning even before the Spaniards first set foot on land and read this foreign document to them.  The natives were ultimately doomed when the pontiff donated the land to the king and queen of Spain. The land that the natives were currently living on.  Therefore all the justification and posturing was not necessary nor did it make any difference in the end.  In the end, the Spaniards were simply being polite and official in their takeover of the natives.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Conundrum of Life and Death

Kelsey Harris

ENGL 2210

Blog #10

“The Conundrum of Life and Death”

Life and death are always in question throughout the entirety of the novel.  The whalesmen are always trying to kill the whales before the whales kill them first.  Not only do they have to worry about the whales but also about the storms raging in the frigid seas.

Queequeg is at the forefront of this conundrum between life and death.  Even as he is first introduced, he makes others question him and his actions.  Ishmael first meets him after he tries to sell the last of his “New Zealand heads” to someone in the town (18).  Then Ishmael discovers “the infernal harpooner is a cannibal” after having a discussion with him about his homeland (21).  These first impressions of the islander scare Ishmael, giving him false ideas about what kind of person Queequeg truly is.

Later on, Queequeg saves Tashtego after he falls into whale while drilling oil out of his head.  The “delivery of Tashtego” by Queequeg suggests his care for life and living creatures (308).  Queequeg essentially births Tashtego from the whale representing the essence of life itself.  The question, of which side Queequeg is closer to, life or death, becomes a little clearer due to these events.

The most ironic of the descriptions concerning Queequeg however deals with the coffin.  A coffin commonly represents death to all who see it.  The carpenter of the boat makes Queequeg his own coffin aboard the ship after he falls violently ill, seeming close to death.  Queequeg proceeds to claim that he “has changed his mind about dying” and returns to health (428).  After all this, he paints “a complete theory of the heavens and Earth” onto the coffin (429).  The meaning of the coffin continues to remain in question as well as its purpose in connection to Queequeg.

At the end of the novel, the meaning of the coffin is ultimately determined with the help of Ishmael.  The coffin, after being turned into a life buoy, is able to save Ishmael from certain death.  The coffin was a “black bubble at the axis of the slowly wheeling circle” in the middle of the ocean (509).  It was as if the Fates were determining whether Ishmael would be allowed to survive while everyone else perished.

By the end, Queequeg chooses life over death, the living over the dying.  He started out a cannibal who sold heads for a living.  He started out the enemy who represented violence, roughness, and paganism.  He transformed into a friend who was patient, kind, and gentle.  He chooses to save his friends instead of simply saving himself.  Although he could not physically save Ishmael, through the use of his coffin, he did.  The coffin was changed from a symbol of death to a symbol of life.  Queequeg through it was changed from an image of darkness and death to an image of light and life.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

A Life at Sea: Better than Suicide, but Definitely Close (10)

Stephanie Arrowood

Eng. 2210

22 November 2011

Blog 10

A Life at Sea: Better than Suicide, but Definitely Close

            The sad story of Perth, the blacksmith, appears in chapter 112 of Moby Dick. Perth lives a charmed life with a beautiful young wife and children. He works at his forge in the basement of his house so that he can remain close to his family while working. Perth’s alcoholism, “the Bottle Conjuror, a desperate burglar [that] slid into his happy home,” caused him to lose his home and his family (431). Perth stopped working which caused him to lose his home and eventually lose his wife and children to possible starvation or sickness. After the loss of his family, Perth chooses to go to sea because he “still [had] left in [him] some interior compunctions against suicide” (432). Perth longed for death because of his guilt, so he chose a life at sea instead of suicide.

            Ishmael also chose to board the Pequod rather than commit suicide. He chose this because he felt that he had no place onshore. Choosing to live (and expectedly die) while at sea seems to bestow an honor on a man regardless of his former position while on shore. Perth may have chosen to board the Pequod to seek repentance for himself for causing the death of his family. “Bowing over still further his chronically broken back, he toiled away, as if toil were life itself, and the heavy beating of his hammer the heavy beating of his heart” (431). Perth may try to achieve repentance by incessantly working. This statement shows that working equates providing for and having a family and ceasing to work means ceasing to have a family or a life. This statement also implies that a man is worthless unless he proves his worth by working. “The heavy beating of his hammer, the heavy beating of his heart” suggests that a man does not live unless he works (431). Essentially, a man has to prove his worth to possess worth. Similar to the rules of the society aboard the Pequod, a man aboard the ship is not judged for his color or position, but by his skills and working ability.

          Dying while at sea may hold the highest honor because at sea all men work for their worth. A man’s position or status at sea directly reflects his abilities, not his wealth, color, social status, etc. that a man’s position reflects on land. When Bulkington dies at sea in chapter 23, Ishmael suggests that he has become a god, “Up from the spray of thy ocean-perishing—straight up, leaps thy apotheosis” (95). This is further evidence that dying while at sea is an honor. Perhaps Ishmael wishes for his death at sea to memorialize him in this way, but Perth simply desires to feel worthy of living.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

A Squeeze of the Hand: Melville and His Craziness

Erica Neese

Blog # 9

HONR 2210

22 November 2011

            We encounter in the 94th chapter of Moby Dick the much anticipated, extended metaphor of masturbation involving the spermaceti of the sperm whale which the crew has recently killed. We have learned much of the sperm whale thanks to Ishmael’s various factual rants on facts and characteristics of each type of whale, and we learn that the most common and sought after whale is in fact, the sperm whale. In this chapter, Ishmael tells us, very jubilantly of his experience breaking up the lumpy spermaceti which is extracted from the whale’s head and elaborates very extensively on the pleasures which he enjoys from this task.

            Melville, as we know, has a very unique way of challenging the reader to think within his stories; consequently, this passage is most significant and up for analysis in my opinion. We learn of Ishmael, who already evokes some homosexual tendencies in relation to Queequeg, spanning from their first night together, and many of his actions reflect a unique daintiness. As a result, in this section, Ishmael’s experience with the spermaceti seems to reveal his sexuality definitely. Ishmael says, “Squeeze! squeeze! squeeze! all the morning long; I squeezed that sperm till I myself almost melted into it; I squeezed that sperm till a strange sort of insanity came over me” (Melville 373). Although we see Ishmael’s “insane” actions here, I found this to be directly reflective of Melville’s extreme insanity. I view this chapter as Melville attempting to write of Ishmael’s experience and then before he is aware, his own indulgence in the thought of masturbation and ejaculation ultimately overflows onto the page making the story that much more complex.

            Ishmael experiences an exuberant amount of pleasure from squeezing the spermaceti in the bucket and seems to additionally be enlightened of the thought that everyone should have an opportunity to do such. Ishmael states, “I have perceived that in all cases man must eventually lower, or at least shift, his conceit of attainable felicity; not placing it anywhere in the intellect or the fancy; but in the wife, the heart, the bed, the table, the saddle, the fire-side, the country…I am ready to squeeze case eternally” (Melville 373). On one hand, I believe Melville is implying that man should experiment with his sexuality and seek his own means of “felicity”, or happiness. On the other, I found that Melville might possibly be questioning the essense of happiness and whether or not it is worth it to settle for earthly happiness. He seems to be suggesting that Ishmael is not yet willing to settle, but desirous of spreading his new found happiness. He says, ” let squeeze hands all round; nay, let us all squeeze ourselves into each other; let us squeeze ourselves universally into the very milk and sperm of kindness” (Melville 373). All in all, this chapter is extremely interesting if analyzed and I believe Melville wrote in such a way as to challenge the reader to look more closely at Ishmael’s ecstatic experience analyze whether it is Melville or Ishmael who is more inclined to settle for earthly felicity rather than fanciful thoughts of squeezing the spermaceti forever.

Posted in Erica Neese | 1 Comment

Poor Little Pip?

Melissa Conrad

ENGL 2210

Blog #9          

Poor Little Pip?

                        In Chapter 93, the Castaway, the reader is addressed to the story of Pip being temporarily put in the place of one of the men that usually went on Stubb’s boat to hunt the whales.  The event is noted because it shows the sometimes cruel determination of man, especially in racial context, and the perspective of the ocean as being “God-omnipresent” (371).  When Pip is thrown from the boat and into the whale line during his first hunt, both Tashtego and Stubb had the internal struggle of whether to cut Pip out of the line.  The reader is drawn to the idea that Pip’s life was less important to the men than the capture of the whale.  In fact, Stubb says, “Stick to the boat, Pip, or by the Lord, I won’t pick you up if you jump; mind that.  We can’t afford to lose whales by the likes of you; a whale would sell for thirty times what you would, Pip, in Alabama” (370).  Stubb basically warns Pip to stay in the boat and brings up the fact that the whale’s life has more monetary value than that of black Pip’s.  However, Stubb’s decision to cut the rope the first time showed that he was able to conquer the idea that man could be so cruel. 

The second time he jumps, however, Pip was left to wait.  The text records that Stubb did not mean to leave Pip, but he was left to float in the vast ocean for an hour.  It is in this scene that the reader discovers the intensity of how these men view the ocean.  The text reads, “The sea had jeeringly kept his finite body up, but drowned the infinite of his soul. Not entirely, though. Rather carried down alive to wondrous depths” (371).  The ocean consumes his soul, where it speaks of Pip being able to acquire a sense of wisdom from the God-omnipresent place.  The shipmates saw him as mad, but Pip was really in this water-world of complete sanity in his eyes.  This separation from his humanity leaves the reader to question if the sea could be some sort of portal to all things godly.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Till Death Do Us Part

Erica Lowery

22 November 2011

Hughes

Blog 11

Till Death Do Us Part

 

Melville introduces many different characters throughout the book. These characters range from all over the globe, ranging from a cannibal like Queequeg to tiny black boy, Pip. It is perceived that Ishmael is the main character of Moby Dick. Melville switches on and off to introduce and explain his characters very well. It is seen within the beginning of the story that the men have security objects. It could be concluded that these men possibly have these objects to relieve them about their insecurities of being in an unknown environment. Even though the men might love the sea they might also fear it a bit as well. As what was said in the very beginning of the pages the sea is feared because it is the ungraspable unknown.

It is obvious that Quequeeg’s “security blanket” is his harpoon. It is the only thing that he has from his homeland. It is rather sharp and dangerous. Even though Queequeq looks dangerous he truly is a gentle giant with shrunken heads dangling from his harpoon. Stubb, the shipman, clings to his pipe. He could be physical characterized has having the pipe a part of his face. Lastly, it is believed that Ishmael security object is rather a person, Queequeg. After their first ackward night together, the two became like lovers. Melville made out Ishmael to be more attached to Queequeg because he had a larger fear of the sea.

Queequeg and Ishmael were polar opposite of one another. They were from two different worlds. Ishmael was from America. Queequeg was from a foreign island where the lower men of the class were made plump so they were sat on by the rich upper class islanders.  Ishmael was a Christian that grew up in a Presbyterian Church while Queequeg was a cannibal that worshiped a wooden idol. Most men of this time would just have of criticized or disregarded a man that had a wooden idol. Ishmael at this time never questioned Queequeg , rather instead Ishmael questioned his  own faith and worship. He connected with his religion that Queequeg was no different from him and should not be treated any differently. Melville chose to make this book full of white and black analogies and what is wrong or right analogies. He makes out Queequeg to be so different but truly he is not. Melville strives for his readers to realize how urgent it is for us to join hands and accept each other. This can be seen in a statement by Ishmael “ How then could I unite with this wild idolator in worshipping his pieve of wood? But what is worship? Thought I. Do you suppose now, Ishmael, that the magnanimous God of heven and earth- pagans and all included- can possible be jealous of an insignificant bit of black wood? Impossible! But what is worship? – to do the will of God? – that is worship. And what is the will of God? – to do to my fellow man what I would have my fellow man to do to me – that is the will of God. Now, Queequeg is my fellow man. And what to do I wish that this Queequeg would do to me? Why, unite with me in my particular Presbyterian form of worship. Consequently, I must then unite with him in his; ergo, I must turn idolator”. This quote epitomizes what most men can’t realize even in this day of age.  This quote could be applied to all wars, discrepancies, church versus state arguments. It can be applied to most all religions as well.

Coinciding, this also showed Ishmael commitment to Queequeg. It shows a lasting relationship and bond between the two before they embarked on their adventure. Melville even refers to the two as man and wife who have “opened the bottom of their souls to one another”. It is clear that Ishmael is the woman and Queequeg is the man. In conclusion, different races and religions at least need to respect one another for our world to be a lot more peaceful and to have couples like Queequeg and Ishmael.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment